Roof Replacement or Repair - How do you know which?

Roof Replacement or Repair

Roof replacement

I am frequently asked by customers if I think its time for them to have a roof replacement. My answer is always the same. Its time for a new roof when you are tired of paying for repairs. It really is that simple. You can read my blog about "do I need a new roof?" HERE. But, for the purposes of this blog, let’s assume you’re the federal government of rich movie star and financing a new roof is no problem. You just want to make sure you’re not throwing money away. As it turns out, there is a system to determine when it doesn’t make sense to repair a roof anymore.

The Army Corps of Engineers developed a system of measuring the components of a roof to determine how many years it has left until it needs a roof replacement or to repair it. This is termed Remaining Service Life (RSL). The program they developed was called ROOFER. I was so enamored by this program that I named this company Preventive Maintenance Support Services instead of something like Kris Irr Roofing. I was sure multi-property owners would pay me well to manage their roof inventories, saving them boatloads of cash by staving off expensive re-roofs. Boy was I silly. Turns out no one cares. Roofs are managed in crisis mode, not good planning. If the roof is leaking get it fixed fast for the cheapest possible price, quality “be dammed”. We can talk about maintenance later say most property managers.

Roofer breaks the roof into three systems. The flashing, insulation and membrane systems categorize into specific defects and density, each with severity levels (low, medium and high). An example is

BF, 10, Low: This is Base Flashing, density 10%, severity Low. Density being the percentage of the defect in terms of the total area.

The Corp spent many years of research and effort developing log tables (logarithmic) for each specific defect. There are dozens of them. Each defect table differs from the other. The Base Flashing table looks like this.

One uses the Severity Level curve at the density level to find a deductive value that will be subtracted from a new roofs value of 100. All deficiency deductive values are added together for each system component (membrane, insulation, and flashing) and subtracted from 100 to get the System Performance Value. Values below 25 are considered poor.

Can the Roof Be Repaired Before Replaced It?

Repairs can be cost-effectively made if the overall Roof Condition Index (RCI) is above 25. Here is the formula:

RCI = (0.7 x lowest system condition index) + (0.15 x Sum of remaining condition indexes)

And the Maintenance Repair or Replacement (MRR) recommendations are as follows:

Table 1 MRR Recommendations

RCI                         Recommendation

86 - 100                Routine Maintenance

71 - 85                  Minor Repairs Needed

56- 70                    Moderate Repairs Needed

41 - 55                  Major Repairs Needed

26- 40                   Replacement Probable

11 - 25                  Replacement Needed

1 - 10                     Replacement Critical

Signs You Need a Roof Replacement

The obvious signs you need a roof replacement are an increase in the frequency of new roof leaks. Poor appearance may be an indication of its condition. A roof system deterioration is exponential, not linear. A roofing system that develops a leak in 10 years may only take two additional years to develop a second leak. The Roofer program has the definitive answer to the question “Do I need a new roof?”. If an objective and exhaustive inspection, made by a qualified professional, is completed and the numbers crunched, the drop-dead date for your roof can be calculated precisely.

When You Need Roof Repair

Roof repair

Assuming your roof is not completely toasted, a roof repair is in order whenever it leaks. Even if you plan on replacing the roof it’s a good idea to mitigate your damage roof inside with at least a quick repair before you consider doing a complete roof replacement or re-roof. But in general, the quality of the repair is important. Most home and building owners don’t consider the quality of the workmanship. They are focused on the price instead. The figure below really spotlights the importance of a well planned and executed roof repair.

The first curve represents the natural deterioration of a roof. We can observe the Remaining Service Life (RSL) by moving horizontally from the RCI calculated above. In this example an RCI of 75 at year 15 will fall to 25 at age 23, if nothing is done. It has an RSL of 8 years. However, if adequate repairs focusing on the defects discovered in the inspection are completed, the RCI will improve to 87. The RSL increases to 11 years. Therefore, the repairs provide an Additional Service (ASL) of 3 years. The ASL of the repairs will only be realized if the repairs are of top quality. One can even use the cost of the repairs to qualify how much each year ASL costs in dollars. An important nugget to consider before pulling the trigger and authorizing the work.

How You Pay a Roof Replacement and Repair

There is always the good old fashion way just paying out of pocket to do roof replacement or repair. But for most of us, financing is probably a better option. Most tile roofs cost about $20,000.00. A five-year loan will have about $500.00 per month payments. There is also a loan option taken against the equity in your home. There is no credit check and the load does not appear on your credit report. You borrow the money and your tax bill increases.

Insurance can pay for some roof replacement or repair. I have several customers that I have made 5 or more repairs for them. They have big homes and they are waiting for a hurricane to blow through. It’s a bit sketchy but not as big a stretch as you might think. Each of these customers is going to wait for at least a “near miss” hurricane. Then they will hire a public adjuster and file a lawsuit. The plaintiff will have an advantage with a jury that will have no sympathy for the insurer. The downside, of course, is that a direct hit hurricane may level the house and while it might be covered by insurance, who wants to live through that?

Getting Reimbursed for a Roof Replacement

I have seen customers go out of pocket after a near-miss hurricane and must do roof replacement. When complete they make an insurance claim. Since the roof is gone and now new, there is nothing for the insurer to inspect. There is nothing but an angry client claiming their roof was so bad they had to protect their home and replace it. These cases also end up in court with an unsympathetic jury and believe it or not, have a high rate of success.

Contact us

Phone Call

Text Message


No Comments Yet.

Leave a comment